When the lender says no: financing and property approval in a Texas contract

Most of a Texas resale contract assumes the buyer and the seller will get to closing. One addendum is written for the case where they will not: the Third Party Financing Addendum, TREC No. 40-11, revision 11-04-2024, which the resale contract pulls in whenever the purchase depends on a loan. It is short, it is almost entirely blank fields, and it is where a buyer's earnest money is protected or lost.
This page describes what the addendum says, in its own words, and how it fits next to the lender's own paperwork. It is not legal advice and it deliberately prints no rate, no fee and no day count: the addendum's numbers are blanks the parties fill in.
The addendum defines success before it defines failure
Paragraph 2 of the addendum is one sentence long, and everything else in it hangs off that sentence:
"Approval for the financing described above will be deemed to have been obtained when Buyer Approval and Property Approval are obtained. Time is of the essence for this paragraph and strict compliance with the time for performance is required."
Two approvals, not one. Buyer Approval is about the borrower. Property Approval is about the house. A contract can fail on either, and each has its own deadline and its own evidence requirement.
Paragraph 1 sets the buyer's duty and the boxes the parties check. The duty: "Buyer shall apply promptly for all financing described below and make every reasonable effort to obtain approval for the financing, including but not limited to furnishing all information and documents required by Buyer's lender." The boxes then describe the loan the contract is counting on — conventional first (and, separately, second) mortgage loans, a Texas Veterans Loan, FHA insured, VA guaranteed, USDA guaranteed, reverse mortgage, or other financing — and each one asks for a principal amount, a term, the maximum interest rate for the first year(s) of the loan, and a cap on "Origination Charges as shown on Buyer's Loan Estimate for the loan".
That last field is the one buyers skim. The paragraph ties the ceiling the buyer agrees to to the Loan Estimate — the federally required disclosure of the loan terms and closing costs — rather than to a number quoted in conversation. The "other financing" box carries one more choice: whether the buyer waives "all rights to terminate the contract under Paragraph 2B of this addendum for the loan described in this paragraph".
Buyer Approval: the borrower, and a statement from the lender
Paragraph 2A is a checkbox decision, and its two options are not symmetrical.
If the contract is subject to Buyer Approval:
"If Buyer cannot obtain Buyer Approval, Buyer may terminate this contract within ___ days after the Effective Date of the contract by giving Seller: (i) notice of termination; and (ii) a copy of a written statement from the lender setting forth the reason(s) for lender's determination. If Buyer terminates the contract under this provision, this contract will terminate and the earnest money will be refunded to Buyer."
Two details carry weight. The exit runs a fixed number of days from the Effective Date — the same date that starts the earnest money and option fee clock in paragraph 5 of the contract, so a short window and a slow lender do not fit together comfortably. And the buyer must hand over the lender's written statement of reasons, not a summary of a phone call.
The paragraph also defines when approval counts as obtained — "when (i) the terms of the loan(s) described above are available and (ii) lender determines that Buyer has satisfied all of lender's requirements related to Buyer's assets, income and credit history" — and what happens if the buyer does not use the exit: "If Buyer does not terminate the contract under Paragraph 2A, the contract shall no longer be subject to the Buyer obtaining Buyer Approval."
The other checkbox is the buyer saying the contract is not subject to Buyer Approval at all. That is a real choice with a real consequence: the borrower-side risk moves onto the buyer.
Property Approval: the appraisal, the insurance and the repairs
Paragraph 2B is the one that answers the question this site gets asked most often about appraisals:
"If Buyer's lender determines that the Property does not satisfy lender's underwriting requirements for the loan (including but not limited to appraisal, insurability, and lender required repairs) Buyer may terminate this contract on or before the 3rd day before the Closing Date by giving Seller: (i) notice of termination; and (ii) a copy of a written statement from the lender setting forth the reason(s) for lender's determination."
Three features are worth holding on to:
- The trigger is the lender's determination, on appraisal, insurability or lender-required repairs — not the buyer's opinion of the house.
- The window is late: on or before the third day before closing. It runs close to the finish line, unlike the option period in paragraph 5 of the contract, which is short and unconditional.
- The evidence is the same shape: notice plus the lender's written statement. If the buyer does not terminate under 2B, "Property Approval is deemed to have been obtained".
The 5% figure that buyers hear about is in the contract rather than the addendum. Paragraph 7E of the resale contract states that, unless the parties agree otherwise in writing, "neither party is obligated to pay for lender required repairs, which includes treatment for wood destroying insects"; if the parties do not agree to pay them, the contract terminates and the earnest money is refunded — and "if the cost of lender required repairs and treatments exceeds 5% of the Sales Price, Buyer may terminate this contract and the earnest money will be refunded to Buyer."
FHA and VA: where the appraisal becomes a federal condition
Paragraph 4 of the addendum is the FHA/VA required provision, and it is stricter than 2B because it is not tied to the buyer's lender alone. It states that "notwithstanding any other provision of this contract", the buyer is not obligated to complete the purchase or to "incur any penalty by forfeiture of earnest money deposits or otherwise":
- unless the buyer has been given, in accordance with HUD/FHA or VA requirements, "a written statement issued by the Federal Housing Commissioner, Department of Veterans Affairs, or a Direct Endorsement Lender setting forth the appraised value of the Property of not less than $_____", or
- "if the contract purchase price or cost exceeds the reasonable value of the Property established by the Department of Veterans Affairs".
And it adds one sentence that separates it from every other deadline in the contract: "The 3-day notice of termination requirement in Paragraph 2B does not apply to this Paragraph 4."
Three sub-paragraphs then describe the buyer's choices and the limits:
- The buyer may proceed anyway: "The Buyer shall have the privilege and option of proceeding with consummation of the contract without regard to the amount of the appraised valuation or the reasonable value established by the Department of Veterans Affairs."
- With FHA financing, the appraisal sets a ceiling, not a warranty: "the appraised valuation is arrived at to determine the maximum mortgage the Department of Housing and Urban Development will insure. HUD does not warrant the value or the condition of the Property. The Buyer should satisfy himself/herself that the price and the condition of the Property are acceptable."
- With VA financing, the gap is cash: if the buyer elects to complete the purchase above the VA reasonable value, "Buyer shall pay such excess amount in cash from a source which Buyer agrees to disclose to the VA and which Buyer represents will not be from borrowed funds except as approved by VA". And if the VA reasonable value is below the sales price, "Seller may reduce the Sales Price to an amount equal to the VA reasonable value and the sale will be closed at the lower Sales Price with proportionate adjustments to the down payment and the loan amount."
That is the whole of what the promulgated form does about a low appraisal. It gives an FHA or VA buyer a federal backstop, and it gives any buyer a lender-determination exit under 2B with a written statement attached. What it does not do is create a general right to renegotiate the price on a conventional loan: nothing in the form makes the seller reopen a number because an appraiser disagreed with it. VA loans and veteran benefits in Texas covers the VA side of these figures in more detail.
The rest of the addendum, in brief
- Security (paragraph 3). "If required by Buyer's lender, each note for the financing described above must be secured by vendor's and deed of trust liens."
- Information sharing (paragraph 5). The buyer authorises the lender to give the seller, buyer or their representatives information about the status of the financing approval. Both parties authorise the lender, the title company and the escrow agent to disclose and furnish "a copy of the closing disclosures and settlement statements" to the parties' respective brokers and sales agents. In plain terms: the paperwork you would rather keep private is, by agreement, shared with the people on the other side of the table.
What this page will not do
It prints no interest rate, no origination charge, no appraisal figure and no day count, because the addendum prints none — every one of them is a blank the parties complete, and a page that filled them in would be inventing the terms of your contract. It also cannot tell you whether a particular house will satisfy a particular lender, or what a particular appraiser will conclude; that determination belongs to the lender, and under 2B it is the lender's written statement that carries the weight.
The Buyer Offer Planner does the arithmetic that sits behind these choices and nothing else: enter the asking price and your adjustment from it, what you would put in the contract, how you would pay for it, and the taxes, insurance and dues attached to the property, and it returns your offer price, the contract deposit deadlines and the cash you would need before and at closing, with every figure tagged entered or computed. No rate is looked up, and the tool does not predict an appraisal.
Where to go next
- What happens at a San Antonio closing — the settlement table where the lender's conditions finally meet the money.
- How much home can I afford in San Antonio — the ceiling that decides how much room a buyer has when a number moves.
- VA loans and veteran benefits in Texas — the VA figures, with the VA's own dates.
- Buyer Offer Planner.
Tool
Buyer Offer Planner
Your offer plan
Nothing is calculated yet
Enter the asking price on the home you have in mind, or the price you want to offer, and this column fills itself in. We will not put a price on a home for you, and we will not assume a rate, a tax rate or an insurance premium: every figure comes from a box you filled in.
When a price exists you will see the offer, the option period and deposit deadlines that go in the contract, the monthly cost at your offer next to the asking price, the cash you would need, and anything in your own numbers that contradicts itself.
