Seller concessions in a Texas purchase: the capped dollar line, and the VA's four percent

The situation
A composite example — not a real buyer, seller or contract.
A San Antonio household has found the house, agreed a price, and then discovers the cash problem is not the price at all — it is the money that has to be in the title company's account on closing day. The buyer asks the seller for help with closing costs, the seller agrees to "cover some of it", and both sides walk away believing the matter is settled.
It is not settled. Nothing about that conversation is in the contract yet, and the sentence "seller will help with closing costs" is not a number, not a deadline and not an obligation.
The problem
A concession is one of the few places in a Texas resale where a seller's money moves to the buyer's side of the settlement table, and it is written as a capped dollar amount with a defined set of things it may be applied to. It is not a discount on the sales price, it is not cash handed to the buyer, and there is a category of expense it may never be applied to at all.
So the questions are concrete. Where in the contract does a concession actually live. What may the money be spent on, and what is excluded. What happens when a government loan programme forbids the buyer from paying a particular fee. And for the many households in this market buying with a VA entitlement, what the VA's own cap is, and what the VA counts as a concession.
What the sources say
Two authorities carry this page, and they answer different halves of the question: the Texas form that allocates the expenses, and the Department of Veterans Affairs page that caps what a seller may give a VA buyer.
The contract writes it as a dollar amount with a ceiling
Paragraph 12 of TREC's promulgated resale contract, form 20-19, revision 05-04-2026, is headed "SETTLEMENT AND OTHER EXPENSES", and it divides the closing bill into two lists. The seller's list, paragraph 12A(1), covers releases of existing liens including prepayment penalties and recording fees, release of the seller's loan liability, tax statements or certificates, preparation of the deed, one-half of the escrow fee, and "other expenses payable by Seller under this contract".
Then the concession itself, as the second item on the seller's side:
"an amount not to exceed $_____________ to be applied to Buyer's Expenses other than brokerage compensation or contributions under Paragraph 12B below."
Three things are visible in that one line. It is a blank with a ceiling, so the amount is a number the parties write in. It is directed at the buyer's expenses, which paragraph 12A(2) then itemises. And it excludes brokerage compensation — the one category a concession cannot be spent on. (Texas Real Estate Commission, One to Four Family Residential Contract (Resale), TREC No. 20-19, revision 05-04-2026, retrieved 23 October 2026.)
What the money may be applied to
Paragraph 12A(2) lists the buyer's expenses the concession can reach, and the list is long and specific: appraisal fees; loan application fees; origination charges; credit reports; preparation of loan documents; interest on the notes from disbursement to one month before the first payment; recording fees; copies of easements and restrictions; the loan title policy with endorsements the lender requires; loan-related inspection fees; photos; amortization schedules; one-half of the escrow fee; all prepaid items, including required premiums for flood and hazard insurance, reserve deposits for insurance, ad valorem taxes and special governmental assessments; the final compliance inspection; courier fee; repair inspection; underwriting fee; wire transfer fee; expenses incident to any loan; and, "as required by the lender", the Private Mortgage Insurance Premium, VA Loan Funding Fee or FHA Mortgage Insurance Premium.
That list is where a buyer should start when working out how much help is actually needed. A concession is not measured against the whole closing bill; it is measured against these lines, and the prepaid items in particular — taxes, hazard premiums, reserves — are often the largest part of what a household has to bring to the table.
Brokerage compensation is a separate paragraph, and it is not part of this
The exclusion in the concession line is not an oversight. Paragraph 12B gives brokerage compensation its own paragraph, and its first sentence is worth reading slowly: "Brokerage compensation is not set by law and is fully negotiable." The form then states that "Each party shall pay their respective brokers pursuant to the terms of the parties' obligations to compensate their brokers contained in separate written agreements."
So the contract keeps three things apart: what the seller pays, what the buyer pays, and what each side owes its own broker under a separate agreement. A concession is a payment between the parties about expenses; it is not a mechanism for one side to fund the other side's representation.
When a loan programme bars the buyer from paying a fee
There is a paragraph that only matters when a government programme is involved, and when it applies it redirects the money. Paragraph 12C, "EXPENSE LIMITATION":
"If a governmental loan program regulation prohibits Buyer from paying charges or fees, then the amount of any concession in 12A(1)(b) shall be first applied to pay such prohibited expenses and then to other Buyer's Expenses but not brokerage compensation or contribution."
Read plainly: if a programme says the buyer may not pay a particular charge, the concession is spent on that charge first, before it can help with anything else on the list. A household counting on a concession to cover an appraisal or a title policy line may find the lender's programme directs it somewhere else entirely.
The VA's own cap, in the VA's own words
For a VA-backed loan the cap comes from the Department of Veterans Affairs, and the page states it directly:
"We allow home sellers or builders to offer credits to cover some or all of the buyer's closing costs. We don't limit credits for a loan's closing costs, but we do limit seller's concessions to no more than 4% of your home's reasonable value. You can find your home's reasonable value in the VA Notice of Value that your lender provided to you."
The same page defines the term more broadly than most buyers expect:
"Seller's concessions are anything of value added to the transaction at no additional cost to the buyer. Concessions include credits for the VA Funding Fee, debt payoff, or prepayment of the buyer's hazard insurance."
That definition matters in two directions. It is wide — a credit toward the funding fee, a payoff of a debt, a prepayment of the buyer's hazard insurance all count — which means a seller's help can take forms that do not look like closing costs. And because it is wide, it is capped as a whole: the VA's limit is on the concessions, not on one line item inside them. (U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, "VA funding fee and loan closing costs", last updated 5 October 2026, retrieved 23 October 2026.)
The VA page also lists the closing costs a buyer can expect on a VA loan — loan discount points, credit report and any credit balances or judgments, the VA appraisal fee, hazard insurance and real estate taxes, state and local taxes, title insurance and the recording fee — which is the list a buyer should be comparing the concession against, line by line, before deciding how much to ask for.
What this page will not do
It states no cap for FHA, USDA, conventional or any other loan programme. Those programmes publish their own limits and none of them was fetched for this page, so naming a percentage would be inventing one. It gives no dollar figure for any concession and no advice on how much to ask a seller for — that is a negotiation, and the ceiling is the buyer's own cash need against the programme's cap. It does not characterise the tax treatment of a concession, does not describe how a concession appears on a Closing Disclosure beyond the contract's own allocation, and does not address seller-paid points, rate buydowns or lender-paid structures as separate mechanisms. It does not quote Paragraph 12B's contribution provisions, which the concession line points at but which this page does not reproduce. It is not legal, tax or financial advice, and it is not a statement about any particular contract, lender or programme.
Where to go next
- Title insurance in Texas: the state-set price, the extras, and who pays — the buyer's list in paragraph 12A(2), line by line, and which of those lines is regulated.
- Which numbers on your Loan Estimate can change — the tolerance rule that governs what a lender may charge against its own estimate.
- VA loans and veteran benefits in Texas — the funding fee that a concession may lawfully cover, and the exemptions from it.
- What happens at a San Antonio closing — where the seller's money and the buyer's money meet, and what the title company does with both.
- Repairs after the inspection: how a Texas contract handles what the report found — the other way a seller ends up paying for something on the buyer's side of the table.
- First-time buyer help in Texas: programs that exist — the agency programmes whose assistance is a third route to the same cash problem.
- Buyer Offer Planner.
Practical next steps
- Read paragraph 12A(1)(b) of the contract and find the dollar amount. If the blank is empty, there is no concession, whatever was said in the conversation.
- Ask the lender, before the offer is written, what the loan programme's cap on seller concessions is — and for a VA loan, remember the cap is measured against the reasonable value on the Notice of Value, not against the price in the contract.
- Total the buyer's own expenses from the paragraph 12A(2) list, starting with the prepaid items, so the request is sized against a real number rather than a guess.
- Do not expect a concession to cover brokerage compensation. The contract excludes it, and each side pays its own broker under a separate agreement.
- If a government programme is involved, ask the lender which of the buyer's fees the programme forbids the buyer to pay, because paragraph 12C sends the concession there first.
- For a VA loan, keep the definition in view: a credit toward the funding fee, a debt payoff and a hazard-insurance prepayment all count as concessions, so they share the same cap.
- Get the agreed amount into the contract in writing before the option period ends, and check the final settlement statement against it rather than assuming it landed.
The takeaway
A concession is not a discount on the house; it is a capped dollar amount in the contract, spent on a defined list of the buyer's expenses, never on broker compensation, and capped again by whichever loan programme is funding the purchase.
The Buyer Offer Planner works out the cash a household needs before and at closing from the figures typed into it, and it holds no concession line at all. If a seller is contributing, this page is the contract paragraph that decides how that contribution is written and what it can reach.
Tool
Buyer Offer Planner
Your offer plan
Nothing is calculated yet
Enter the asking price on the home you have in mind, or the price you want to offer, and this column fills itself in. We will not put a price on a home for you, and we will not assume a rate, a tax rate or an insurance premium: every figure comes from a box you filled in.
When a price exists you will see the offer, the option period and deposit deadlines that go in the contract, the monthly cost at your offer next to the asking price, the cash you would need, and anything in your own numbers that contradicts itself.
