Rent or buy in San Antonio? Run the arithmetic yourself

Two questions get folded into one when somebody asks whether they should keep renting or buy. The first is about a house: what it would really cost to own the one you have in mind. The second is about you: how long you would stay in it, and what you think happens to its value while you do. Only the first is a market question, and this page answers neither of them with a statistic. The second is arithmetic — and done honestly, it decides the whole answer.
What this page is, and what it is not
What this is. A guided way to put the two things side by side — what you would pay to keep renting, and what owning the home you have in mind would really cost once taxes, insurance, upkeep and the costs of buying and of selling are in the same row. It answers one question: in what year does owning come out ahead on your own numbers, and how much does that answer move if you stay longer, pay a different rate, or the home grows in value?
What it is not. It is not a prediction about San Antonio's market and not a recommendation to rent or buy. We hold no listings, we look up no rents, prices, rates, tax rates or insurance premiums, and we quote no market statistic. Every figure in the answer is one you typed or one of the labelled assumptions listed beside it. Arithmetic on your numbers can tell you what your own assumptions imply — it cannot tell you what a home is worth, what it will be worth, or what you should do.
That is the whole honesty policy behind this page, and it decides what follows: the figures below are context you can check for yourself, and the comparison they feed is the Rent or Buy tool.
The two figures that decide almost every answer
Strip away the opinions and two numbers move the answer more than everything else combined.
How long you would stay. The costs of buying and of selling are paid once and land in the first year and the last one. Spread over thirty years they are a rounding error; spread over two they are the decision. The tool's stay-length slider runs from one year to thirty, and the verdict moves as you drag it — which is the honest shape of the problem. A household that might move in three years and a household that will still be there in fifteen are not deciding the same question, even if they are looking at the same house.
What you assume the home's value does. This is the figure most people never write down. In the tool it starts blank, and blank means zero: the arithmetic assumes the home is worth what you paid for it when you sell — no growth, no loss — and it says so on the result page. Put a number in only if you want to see what your own guess would do to the answer. Nobody can tell you what a home will be worth, and we will not pretend to; a number you chose and can see is worth more than a number we invented.
At the tool's labelled defaults, with value growth left blank, the arithmetic honestly reports renting ahead for a long time. That is not a judgement about San Antonio and it is not a bug. It is what buying looks like when the home does not appreciate and the stay is short, and the sensitivity lines exist to show you which way that changes.
What rent looks like here: the one public figure we can date
There is no official series of asking rents for San Antonio homes, and we publish no local rent figure of our own. What exists is a federal program parameter, and it is worth knowing what it is before anyone repeats it at you.
The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development sets Fair Market Rents each year. HUD defines them as "estimates of 40th percentile gross rents for standard quality units within a metropolitan area or nonmetropolitan county", and its current methodology describes them as HUD's "best estimate of the 40th percentile of rents paid by recent movers" (HUD, Fair Market Rents dataset page; and "Calculation of HUD Fair Market Rents", updated July 2025, retrieved 23 September 2026). For FY 2026, the metro-wide figures for the San Antonio-New Braunfels, TX HUD Metro FMR Area — which covers Bandera, Bexar, Comal, Guadalupe and Wilson counties — are:
- 0 bedrooms (efficiency): $1,077
- 1 bedroom: $1,177
- 2 bedrooms: $1,426
- 3 bedrooms: $1,830
- 4 bedrooms: $2,132
Read them for what they are. They are effective from 1 October 2025 and were republished unchanged in the revision effective 21 May 2026 (HUD, FY 2026 FMR county-level data files and schedule, retrieved 23 September 2026). They are the rent levels HUD uses to set payment standards in the Housing Choice Voucher program — not asking rents, not sale prices, and not a prediction. They are a floor-of-the-market statistic built from survey data, which is why they generally sit below what a new lease asks in a tight neighborhood.
One more caveat belongs with the number, because it keeps the figure honest: San Antonio-New Braunfels is also a Small Area Fair Market Rent area, and HUD publishes a second, ZIP-by-ZIP schedule for this metro. Those ZIP-level figures differ from the metro-wide ones in both directions — HUD's FY 2026 schedule lists a two-bedroom at $1,220 for ZIP 78227 and $1,530 for ZIP 78230, against the metro-wide $1,426 (HUD, FY 2026 Small Area FMR Schedule, retrieved 23 September 2026). So the honest sentence is: this is HUD's metro-wide FY 2026 40th-percentile figure for the area, and your own rent is the number that belongs in the comparison — the one you actually pay.
What a home costs here: the pieces we can date
The owning side has more parts, and each one has a different kind of answer.
The price. List prices are asking prices, and the one we can date is the median list price for the San Antonio-New Braunfels metro in August 2026: $324,000, published by Realtor.com among its monthly housing data (Realtor.com, residential data, August 2026, retrieved 23 September 2026). That is the middle of what sellers were asking — not the middle of what buyers paid, and not a claim about any particular house. The price in your comparison is a house you have in mind, and you type it.
The mortgage. We quote no rate. Your rate depends on your lender, your credit and the day you lock, and any number we printed would be out of date by the time you read it and would be ours, not yours. The tool's rate field starts at a labelled assumption with a badge saying it is one, and it is one tap from being replaced by your own.
Property taxes. In Texas a tax bill is a stack, not a rate. The county, the city, the school district, the community college district, the hospital district, a river authority and — in some places — an emergency services district each levy their own rate on the same property, and each of those rates is published by the Comptroller for every taxing unit, which is how two addresses a few miles apart can carry different school, city and special-district rates at the same time (Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts, "Tax Rates and Levies", 2025 edition listed at retrieval). The homestead exemption then applies against specific parts of that stack rather than against the whole bill — Texas' school-district residence homestead exemption is $140,000 in the Comptroller's January 2026 publication (Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts, "Texas Property Tax Exemptions", publication 96-1740, January 2026). The mechanics are set out in How much home can you afford in San Antonio?. The tool asks for a percentage and badges it as an assumption, because the rate that matters is the one on a specific address's own notice.
Homeowners insurance. The one figure we can date is statewide: the Texas Department of Insurance reports an average annual homeowners premium of $3,506, labelled 2025 preliminary, drawn from the Texas Statistical Plan for Residential Risks (Texas Department of Insurance, "Texas homeowners insurance market overview", retrieved 23 September 2026). It is a state market statistic, not a quote for a house. What a specific address pays depends on the home, its age, its roof and where it sits. The tool's monthly insurance figure is a labelled assumption you should replace with a quote.
Mortgage insurance. On a conventional loan, private mortgage insurance is generally required when the down payment is less than 20 percent of the price, and is not required at 20 percent (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, "What is private mortgage insurance?", last reviewed 28 August 2023). The tool applies that rule to whatever down payment you enter. It does not model the point at which mortgage insurance drops off the loan later, and it says so.
Upkeep. No agency publishes a maintenance percentage, because there is no such official figure. The tool's one-percent default is a placeholder with a badge saying so, to be replaced with your own estimate of repairs, replacements and the things that break — or set to zero if you would rather see the answer without it.
The costs of buying and of selling. Closing costs on the way in and selling costs on the way out are the two figures people leave out of a rent-versus-buy comparison, and they are the ones that most often flip a short stay. We publish no local figure for either, on purpose: they depend on the loan, the lender, the title company and the deal. The tool asks you for your own percentage for each, and if you leave one blank the owning side tells you it has left that cost out — and tells you which way the omission leans.
The parts the arithmetic does not model
Honesty here is a list, not a slogan. The comparison is silent about the following, and a result page that hid that would be selling you something:
- What the down payment would have earned if it had been invested instead. That opportunity cost is real and it is not in the numbers.
- Renters insurance, which renting costs and this comparison does not charge to the rent side.
- Rising ownership costs. Taxes, insurance, association dues and maintenance are held flat in this arithmetic even though they rarely stay flat — an asymmetry that flatters owning, and we would rather say so than bury it.
- Mortgage insurance dropping off once the loan is paid down.
- Reassessment after a purchase, which in Texas can move the taxable value a bill is built on.
The tool states each of these on the result page, in one sentence apiece, next to the numbers they affect.
What would change the answer
The last block of the result is four hypotheticals, each a re-run of the same arithmetic with one thing changed: a shorter stay, a longer stay, a higher rate, rent rising faster, more maintenance, or ownership costs climbing each year. Each line begins with "If", because that is what it is — and the block says so: these are hypotheticals, not predictions.
Read them in the other direction too. If the arithmetic says buying is ahead on your numbers, the same block tells you what would put renting back in front, and if the answer is close, it will say so rather than manufacture a verdict. Approximations have a habit of looking like decisions; the honest version of "close" is the word "close".
Run it on your own numbers
The comparison is Rent or Buy: seven steps, one question on screen at a time, and a verdict panel that updates while you type. Only two things are required — what you pay to live where you live now, and the price of the home you have in mind. Everything else is a labelled assumption you can see, changing the answer live, with the ones that are yours to know left blank until you fill them in.
What you get at the end: the year owning pulls ahead if it does, or the plain statement that it does not within thirty years; the first year's monthly difference; a year-by-year table of both sides; and the four sensitivity lines above. Every figure is labelled with where it came from — you entered it, or it is an assumption you can edit. The engine is rent-or-buy-v1, it computes arithmetic on your entries and nothing else, and no AI produced any of the numbers. When there is a result worth keeping you can save it and, if you want one, ask to be put in touch with an expert who works in this market.
Where to go next
- What the monthly payment on a home would be, on your own numbers: the Mortgage & Affordability Calculator and How much home can you afford in San Antonio?.
- The four blanks a Texas resale contract leaves open, turned into deadlines and a payment: the Buyer Offer Planner.
- Before you run any of it: what the household actually needs — Writing a house wish list that survives a real search — and which records to read about taxes, insurance, flood and schools for an address, in How to weigh a San Antonio-area location without a rating.
- How a lender measures the rest of your debts: What is a debt-to-income ratio, and why do lenders use it?.
Sources for the facts on this page
- FY 2026 Fair Market Rents, San Antonio-New Braunfels, TX HUD Metro FMR Area — 0BR $1,077, 1BR $1,177, 2BR $1,426, 3BR $1,830, 4BR $2,132, covering Bandera, Bexar, Comal, Guadalupe and Wilson counties, effective 1 October 2025 and republished unchanged in the FY 2026 revision effective 21 May 2026: HUD, FY 2026 FMR county-level data file and the printed FY 2026 schedule, retrieved 23 September 2026.
- The FY 2026 ZIP-by-ZIP figures (2BR $1,220 in ZIP 78227, $1,530 in ZIP 78230 against the metro-wide $1,426): HUD, FY 2026 Small Area FMR Schedule, retrieved 23 September 2026.
- The definition of a Fair Market Rent, the 30-day posting rule and the start-of-fiscal-year effective date: HUD, Fair Market Rents dataset page, retrieved 23 September 2026.
- "HUD's best estimate of the 40th percentile of rents paid by recent movers": HUD, "Calculation of HUD Fair Market Rents", updated July 2025, retrieved 23 September 2026.
- Median list price, San Antonio-New Braunfels metro, $324,000 in August 2026, as a listing price: Realtor.com, residential data, August 2026, retrieved 23 September 2026.
- Median household income, ACS 2024 one-year estimates, Table B19013 ($78,112 metro, $66,176 city): U.S. Census Bureau, 2024 one-year estimates, retrieved 23 September 2026.
- Average annual homeowners premium, Texas, $3,506 labelled 2025 preliminary: Texas Department of Insurance, "Texas homeowners insurance market overview", retrieved 23 September 2026.
- Private mortgage insurance is required when the down payment is less than 20 percent of the price and not required at 20 percent: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, "What is private mortgage insurance?", last reviewed 28 August 2023.
- Tax rates levied by each taxing unit and published by unit and year: Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts, "Tax Rates and Levies", 2025 edition listed at retrieval, retrieved 23 September 2026.
- The $140,000 school-district residence homestead exemption: Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts, "Texas Property Tax Exemptions", publication 96-1740, January 2026, retrieved 23 September 2026.
- Setting the home-price budget before shopping, and the order of the buying process: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, "Buying a house" and "Preparing to shop for your mortgage", retrieved 23 September 2026.
Everything else on this page describes how the Rent or Buy tool works — what it asks, what it computes and what it refuses to claim. It holds no listings, looks up no rents or prices, and is not a source of facts about any market.
Tool
Rent or Buy
What this is. A guided way to put the two things side by side — what you would pay to keep renting, and what owning the home you have in mind would really cost once taxes, insurance, upkeep and the costs of buying and of selling are in the same row. It answers one question: in what year does owning come out ahead on your own numbers, and how much does that answer move if you stay longer, pay a different rate, or the home grows in value?
What it is not. It is not a prediction about San Antonio's market and not a recommendation to rent or buy. We hold no listings, we look up no rents, prices, rates, tax rates or insurance premiums, and we quote no market statistic. Every figure in the answer is one you typed or one of the labelled assumptions listed beside it. Arithmetic on your numbers can tell you what your own assumptions imply — it cannot tell you what a home is worth, what it will be worth, or what you should do.
Every figure is computed by rent-or-buy-v1 from what you type and from the labelled defaults you can see and change — no AI produces any of it.
Nothing is compared yet
Enter what you pay to live there now, and the price of the home you have in mind. The answer appears as you type, and every other figure in it is a labelled assumption you can see and change.
Once you have entered a rent and a price, you can save this answer, email it, or ask an expert about it.
- Enter what you pay to live there now (or what you would pay) and the comparison starts: the rent side is that figure, growing at the rate you set beside it.
- There is no price for the home you have in mind yet, so there is nothing to compare. Enter a price and the owning side fills itself in.
