A real San Antonio listing, run as an investment: the arithmetic

A house for sale is a bundle of claims made by somebody, and the point of this page is to separate the part that is arithmetic from the part that is not. What follows is an educational walkthrough of one example property currently listed on Xome, a real estate marketplace: 3431 Old Almonte Dr in San Antonio, ZIP 78224. Nothing here is a recommendation about the property, the seller, the neighborhood or the future, and no photograph from the listing is reproduced.
Every number below is either something the listing page states, something a government publication states, or arithmetic on an input this page labels as an example. Where a real figure is missing, the page says so instead of supplying one.
The snapshot, straight off the listing page
As they appeared on the Xome listing page when it was retrieved on 24 September 2026:
- List price: $227,500, shown as "List Price", with the listing marked "FOR SALE - ACTIVE".
- 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, 1,242 square feet.
- Year built: the page's Essential Facts field reads 2025, while the listing description says the home was "built in 2024". Two fields on the same page disagree, so the build year is unconfirmed rather than one of the two being picked for you.
- Single family, 1 story, 2-car garage, lot 0.101 acres, Bexar County, subdivision Palo Alto Un 5 Ncb 14552, MLS number 2973385.
- Listing courtesy of Drew Nelson, Real Broker, LLC, which is the attribution the page carries.
- The page's own stamp: last updated 23 September 2026.
Listing status changes — verify current status. A listing can be pending, withdrawn or under contract by the time you read this; the listing page, or the agent you are working with, is where current status lives. That page also carries a school-information block with third-party ratings and an area-statistics block from a commercial data provider. Neither is used here, and nothing on this page makes a claim about the neighborhood.
What the listing page does not show is what this walkthrough needs next: a rent, a tax bill and an insurance premium. The rent comes from a published federal figure, and the other two are labeled placeholders.
Scenario one: a VA loan with nothing down
The Department of Veterans Affairs states that "nearly 90% of all VA-backed home loans are made without a down payment" (VA, "VA-backed home loan types", last updated 19 March 2025, retrieved 24 September 2026). So take the price as the loan amount and look at the payment.
The rate below is an example input, not a quote and not a prediction: 6.0 percent over 30 years. Rates change weekly, which is exactly why the calculator on this site takes the rate from you. On a $227,500 loan:
- Principal and interest: $1,364 a month.
- Property tax: $379 a month, held on a labeled assumption of 2.0 percent of price a year rather than on a published rate. The combined rate for an address is a document, not a number anyone can assume: the county, the city, the school district and any special districts each adopt their own rate annually, and an exemption changes the taxable value. Property taxes in San Antonio: how the bill is built walks through that machinery.
- Insurance: $200 a month, another labeled placeholder at $2,400 a year. Texas does not publish a rate for a house; the deductible you choose and the coverage you set are what move the premium (Texas Department of Insurance, "Home insurance guide", last updated 1 June 2026, retrieved 24 September 2026). The policy itself is covered in Homeowners insurance in Texas: what a policy actually covers.
Total: about $1,943 a month. One real cost is deliberately absent from it. A VA funding fee is part of this loan type and is not in the figure above, because the percentage depends on your service history and on whether it is your first use of the benefit; VA publishes the current chart and the exemptions. In this scenario the fee would be paid at closing or financed, and either way it is money.
The ratio a lender has to hold
That $1,943 is a debt payment, and lenders measure a debt payment against income with a debt-to-income ratio. The number you have seen quoted — 43 percent — is history rather than a current cap: before the 2021 General QM Amendments, Regulation Z section 1026.43(e)(2) defined a Qualified Mortgage partly by a 43 percent ceiling on the total-debt ratio, and the amendments replaced that requirement with annual percentage rate thresholds (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Regulation Z section 1026.43, annotated, retrieved 24 September 2026). What is a debt-to-income ratio, and why do lenders use it? sets out the whole history.
Used as a reasoning tool rather than a rule, 43 percent gives two arithmetic answers on this payment:
- With no other debt, $1,943 divided by 0.43 is about $4,519 a month of gross income, or about $54,200 a year.
- Add $400 a month of other debt payments — a car loan and a credit-card minimum, say — and the same division gives about $5,449 a month, or about $65,400 a year.
Neither figure is an approval. Both are division on inputs you can change, and the calculator lets you set the ratio it targets instead of taking one from a page.
The rent side, from a published figure
For a rent benchmark this page uses HUD's Fair Market Rent for the ZIP code. In HUD's FY 2026 Small Area FMR file, ZIP 78224 sits in the San Antonio-New Braunfels, TX HUD Metro FMR Area, with a three-bedroom FMR of $1,620 a month (U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, FY 2026 Small Area Fair Market Rents, effective 1 October 2025, retrieved 24 September 2026). The same file puts the two-bedroom FMR for that ZIP at $1,260.
Read that figure for what it is. Fair Market Rents are program parameters — the 40th-percentile gross rents HUD uses to set Housing Choice Voucher payment standards — not asking rents, not a rent this house would achieve, and not a forecast of anything.
Gross rent against monthly cost
Now the division that matters, on the labeled inputs above:
- Gross rent, three-bedroom FMR: $1,620 a month, or $19,440 a year.
- Gross rent divided by the list price: 8.5 percent a year. That is a ratio of two inputs, not a return. It is before vacancy, before repairs, before management, before the tax and insurance lines above, before any capital work, and before debt service.
- Price divided by annual gross rent: 11.7. The same two numbers, turned around.
- Monthly cost against gross rent: $1,620 minus $1,943 leaves a gap of about $323 a month, before a single operating expense.
Add three labeled operating assumptions — vacancy at 8 percent of rent, maintenance at 10 percent, and property management at 8 percent, which together are $422 a month — and what remains of the rent is $1,199 a month against $1,364 of principal and interest. On those inputs the monthly figure is negative by about $165, and it is negative before income taxes, before any HOA assessment, and before the funding fee and closing costs a purchase would carry.
That result is the point of doing the arithmetic in the open. It is not a verdict on this house. Three of the inputs are placeholders, and a different rate, tax bill, insurance premium or rent moves the answer — which is why the useful output of a walkthrough like this one is the order of the questions, not a number to act on.
Educational walkthrough, not investment advice
This is an educational walkthrough, not investment advice. Nothing in it recommends buying, selling or holding any property, and nothing in it forecasts a price, a rent or a return. To run the same payment arithmetic on your own rate, down payment, tax and insurance figures, use the Mortgage & Affordability Calculator: it computes from what you enter and fetches nothing.
Tool
Mortgage & Affordability Calculator
Estimated affordable purchase price
$276,984
based on a monthly housing budget of $2,300 after your other debts
- Principal & interest
- $1,575.65
- Property tax
- $415.48
- Insurance
- $160.00
- Mortgage insurance
- $103.87
- HOA
- $45.00
- Total monthly housing cost
- $2,300.00
- Loan amount
- $249,286
- Down payment (10.0%)
- $27,698
- Total interest over 30 yrs
- $317,954
- Total of payments
- $567,239
- Mortgage insurance is included because the down payment is under 20% of the price. Set its rate to 0 to see the estimate without it.
Estimate only. Excludes closing costs, moving costs, repairs, utilities and any change in taxes or insurance over time. Computed by mortgage-v2 from the assumptions above — no AI produced these numbers and no lender has reviewed them.
Do something with this result
